Decision Making is the UCAT subtest with the most question variety — and the one where applicants most often run out of time. Here are 15 worked examples covering every question type you'll face.
How to use this guide
Each example below is structured as: the prompt, the trap, the method, and the answer. Attempt each one yourself first, then check the method. If your approach differs from ours but gets the right answer, that's fine — there's often more than one route.
Syllogisms (3 examples)
Example 1
Prompt: "All doctors own stethoscopes. Some doctors own cars. Can we conclude: some car owners own stethoscopes?"
Trap: Thinking about the real world. In syllogisms, use only the statements given.
Method: Statement 1 says all doctors own stethoscopes. Statement 2 says some doctors own cars. So those "some doctors" (who own cars) also own stethoscopes (because all doctors do). Therefore some car owners (those doctors) own stethoscopes.
Answer: Yes.
Example 2
Prompt: "No cats are dogs. Some pets are cats. Can we conclude: some pets are not dogs?"
Method: Some pets are cats; no cats are dogs; therefore those pets (that are cats) are not dogs. So some pets are not dogs.
Answer: Yes.
Example 3
Prompt: "Most footballers eat pasta. Alex eats pasta. Can we conclude: Alex is probably a footballer?"
Trap: Direction matters. Most footballers eat pasta doesn't mean most pasta eaters are footballers.
Answer: No.
Probability (3 examples)
Example 4
Prompt: A bag has 3 red marbles and 7 blue marbles. You draw 2 without replacement. What's the probability both are red?
Method: First red = 3/10. Second red (now 2 red of 9) = 2/9. Both = 3/10 × 2/9 = 6/90 = 1/15.
Answer: 1/15 (or about 6.7%).
Example 5
Prompt: A test is 90% accurate. 1 in 100 people has the condition. You test positive. What's the chance you have it?
Trap: Not 90%. Base rate matters.
Method: Imagine 1,000 people. 10 have it (90% test positive → 9 true positives). 990 don't (10% false positive → 99 false positives). Of 108 positives, 9 truly have it = 9/108 = about 8.3%.
Answer: About 8%.
Example 6
Prompt: Three dice rolled. Probability of at least one 6?
Method: Easier to calculate P(no 6) = 5/6 × 5/6 × 5/6 = 125/216. So P(at least one) = 1 − 125/216 = 91/216 ≈ 42%.
Answer: 91/216 or about 42%.
Venn diagrams (3 examples)
Example 7
Prompt: In a group of 50 students, 30 study biology, 25 study chemistry, 15 study both. How many study neither?
Method: Biology only = 30 − 15 = 15. Chemistry only = 25 − 15 = 10. Both = 15. Total studying one or more = 15 + 10 + 15 = 40. Neither = 50 − 40 = 10.
Answer: 10.
Example 8
Prompt: Three circles: A, B, C. A = 40, B = 35, C = 30. A∩B = 12, B∩C = 10, A∩C = 8, A∩B∩C = 5. How many only in A?
Method: Only in A = A − (A∩B) − (A∩C) + (A∩B∩C) = 40 − 12 − 8 + 5 = 25.
Answer: 25.
Example 9
Prompt: Of 100 patients, 60 have high blood pressure, 45 have diabetes, 30 have both. How many have high blood pressure but not diabetes?
Method: 60 − 30 = 30.
Answer: 30.
Logic puzzles (2 examples)
Example 10
Prompt: Four people (A, B, C, D) sit in a row. A is not next to B. C is between B and D. In what order do they sit?
Method: C between B and D gives us B-C-D or D-C-B. A is not next to B, so A sits at the other end. Order: A-D-C-B (or its reverse).
Answer: A, D, C, B.
Example 11
Prompt: Three doctors work Mon-Wed-Fri in some order. Dr X doesn't work Monday. Dr Y works the day after Dr Z. Who works when?
Method: Dr Y works the day after Dr Z — so Z/Y are consecutive (M/W or W/F). Dr X isn't Monday, so X = Wednesday or Friday. If Y-Z are M-W, X = F. Check: Z=Mon, Y=Wed, X=Fri. Works.
Answer: Z Mon, Y Wed, X Fri.
Arguments (2 examples)
Example 12
Prompt: "Universities should charge higher fees for high-earning degrees." Which is the strongest argument FOR?
Rule: Strongest = most relevant and most likely true.
Trap: Options that are emotional appeals, or true but irrelevant, or relevant but obviously false.
Approach: Pick the one that directly links higher fees to a positive outcome AND is plausible on its face.
Example 13
Prompt: "Social media should be banned for under-16s." Strongest argument AGAINST?
Approach: Look for the option that both addresses the specific claim and uses plausible reasoning. Options citing general freedoms are usually weaker than options citing specific harms of the ban.
Interpreting the answer (2 examples)
Example 14
Prompt: "A new drug cuts heart attack risk by 50%." A patient's baseline risk is 2%. What's their risk on the drug?
Trap: "By 50%" can mean relative or absolute. In UCAT it's usually relative.
Method: Relative 50% reduction of 2% baseline = 1% absolute risk.
Answer: 1%.
Example 15
Prompt: A survey says 70% of UK adults support policy X. Can we conclude a majority of the UK population supports policy X?
Trap: Adults ≠ total population. Sample selection matters.
Answer: Not from this alone; depends on sample representativeness and whether "UK population" includes under-18s.
What to drill next
Most students have one weak question type. Identify yours (likely probability trees, complex Venn diagrams, or formal syllogisms) and spend 30 minutes a day on just that type for 2 weeks. A tutor can halve the time if they sit beside you in live drills: see our UCAT 1-to-1 tutoring.
Want a tutor to walk through these with you live?
In your 1-to-1 UCAT session we work live DM examples at exam speed, and build the whiteboard habit that cuts your solve time in half. From £50/hr.
See UCAT tutoring →Frequently asked questions
What's a good UCAT Decision Making score?
650+ puts you above average for DM. 700+ is top decile. The subtest is scored 300-900 like the others. Overall UCAT competitive target for 2027 is 2700+ total.
Which DM question type takes the longest?
Complex logic puzzles and multi-condition probability questions. Both take 90+ seconds comfortably. Learn to flag-and-skip these in the real test if you're already behind.
Should I use the UCAT on-screen whiteboard?
Yes, aggressively. Sketch Venn diagrams, probability trees and syllogism chains instead of doing them mentally. It's faster and more accurate.
How many DM mocks should I do?
At least 10 full-length 31-minute DM sections before test day. Also drill individual question types in short bursts between full mocks.
Is DM harder than Verbal Reasoning?
Different kind of hard. VR is a reading speed test; DM is a problem-solving variety test. Most students find DM more fatiguing, especially the logic puzzles.